Every group has a join policy: the rule for how someone becomes a member. There are three, and picking the right one is the difference between a group that fills itself and one that quietly never grows.
Who this is for
Whoever sets up groups, and group leaders handling requests.
The three policies
Open — anyone can join, immediately, without asking. They find the group in the app, tap join, and they're in.
Use this for anything you'd be glad to have more people at: a men's breakfast, a prayer meeting, a walking group. It removes every step between interest and belonging, which is usually the point.
Request — anyone can find the group and ask to join, and a leader approves or declines.
Use this where fit matters or numbers are limited: a home group that meets in a living room, a course with a set start date, a group where an existing member should know who's coming.
Closed — the group doesn't appear when members browse, and nobody can ask to join. An administrator or leader adds people directly.
Use this for teams and anything sensitive: a safeguarding team, elders, a pastoral care group. Closed groups aren't listed at all, so their existence isn't advertised.
Setting it
Open the group and choose the policy. You can change it whenever you like — a group can start closed while it's forming and open up later.
Approving requests
When someone asks to join a request-based group, the request waits for a decision. A leader, co-leader, or administrator can approve or decline it.
Approving adds them to the group straight away. The decision records who made it, so there's a clear trail on a group where membership matters.
Check requests regularly. A join request is someone putting their hand up, and the gap between asking and hearing back is the point at which most people quietly give up. A request sitting unanswered for three weeks reads to that person as a no — and worse, as a no from a church that didn't notice them.
Which to choose
When in doubt, choose open. Most church groups benefit far more from being easy to join than from being controlled, and the friction of approval usually costs you more people than it protects.
Reach for request when there's a real reason: space, timing, or fit. Reach for closed when the membership itself is confidential.
You'll know it worked when…
An open group can be joined directly from the app. A request group shows the request to a leader for approval. A closed group doesn't appear when members browse at all.
If something goes wrong
- Members can't find the group — it's probably closed. Closed groups aren't listed. Switch to open or request, or add the person directly.
- Someone tried to join but nothing happened — for a request group, that's expected; the request is waiting for approval.
- A leader can't see requests — check they're set as leader or co-leader on the group. A facilitator can't approve requests.
- You want to add someone to a closed group — add them directly rather than changing the policy.
Related articles
- Creating a group
- Group roles and what each one can do
- Recording group attendance